Despite the personal bickering, this is still a good conversation. Since I'm late to the party, I'll toss out some of my opinions.
1) In the 90's I was pretty sure guys were juicing. Their bodies were changing too rapidly and abnormally, and at what are typically the declining years of a players career, they were out producing their prime years. The only people who didn't know it was happening, were those who didn't want to know. One thing that floored me, was when we found out just how many guys were using. That was a surprise.
2) I'm not very suspicious of Judge using any additives or preservatives. He's a big guy, in the prime of his career, who has always mashed. And although it's an imperfect science, his body is relatively the same as he looked in his rookie year. And while there will probably always be a lingering degree of suspicion in me, there's not enough for me to question whether he's clean or not.