MLB Network covered did a show on the top 10 for every position. That featured Brian Kenny (recent guest of Sports Tonight), a projection system (not sure specifically what goes into this) called The Shredder, Bill James, and one MLBN analyst that played that position or a similar one.
Rob and I have also been doing our top 10's on the show.
I'll post the lists in this thread.
I'll start with catcher:
Me:
1. Posey
2. Molina
3. Lucroy
4. Gomes
5. Perez
6. McCann
7. Wieters
8. Castro
9. Martin
10. Ramos
Rob:
1. Posey
2. Molina
3. Perez
4. McCann
5. Wieters
6. Lucroy
7. Castro
8. Martin
9. Gomes
10. Salty
Kenny: 1. Posey 2. Molina 3. Santana (we didn't list him at C) 4. McCann 5. Perez 6. Lucroy 7. Castro 8. Ruiz 9. Martin 10. Montero
Shredder: 1. Molina 2. Posey 3. Perez 4. Santana 5. Castro 6. Lucroy 7. Ruiz 8. Montero 9. Rosario 10. Ramos
Dave Valle: 1. Molina 2. Perez 3. Posey 4. Wieters 5. Ramos 6. Martin 7. McCann 8. Ellis 9. Lucroy 10 Castro