I know we're well past this but I want to revisit this question, now that the bottom has dropped out.
If the Orioles were within shouting distance of .500 right now, but Means threw a complete game one-hitter, would you take that trade?
Does being close to .500 have an impact on our future? It probably would have a positive impact on how I view our future, so in that case, I'd take the much better record.
However, from a fan perspective that is limited to strictly this season (no impact on the future), I think I'd rather have the no hitter, especially since I actually watched it. It's also helpful that I mostly checked out on this season a while back besides going to some games, so my time and emotional investment into this awful team is rather minimal.