126 replies to this topic

[JStruds]

So bad.

[BSLChrisStoner]

Called out after review.

So sick of reviews. What's the point?

[You Play to Win the Game]

That’s terrible. To me you could clearly see his left fingers touch the base just before the tag. Bad call, understandable live, inconceivable after replay.

Great throw and tag, that had no business being close.

[mweb08]

The slide made that closer than it should have been.

[85Knight]

He was safe but the camera angles weren't definitive.

[JStruds]

The left hand on the base before the tag is "not definitive". Geez.

[Mike B]

Replay sucks.

[TwentyThirtyFive]

Called out after review.

So sick of reviews. What's the point?

I mean the inconsistency sucks but you still wanna get the obvious misses wrong and there are enough obvious misses

[Mike B]

The left hand on the base before the tag is "not definitive". Geez.

Yep, and Jorge would have scored on Ced's fly ball.

[russsnyder]

It looked like Mateo was safe to me.

Guy can't get a break on the challenges in Houston.

[85Knight]

That throw was pure luck. He picked it up and threw it blindly.

[TwentyThirtyFive]

The conclusive evidence stuff is the BS. Look if the call is 50/50 or 55/45 go with the original call. If its not definitive but it damn sure looks like its one way or the other then change the call. That goes for football too

[mweb08]

The slide made that closer than it should have been.

It was also a great throw.

No issue with the decision to go for the triple.

[mweb08]

The conclusive evidence stuff is the BS. Look if the call is 50/50 or 55/45 go with the original call. If its not definitive but it damn sure looks like its one way or the other then change the call. That goes for football too

Agreed. That's one of my pet peeves with replay.

[russsnyder]

Called out after review.

So sick of reviews. What's the point?

To give the sport the NFL "feel."

I hate replay.

IMO, it should only be used for fan interference, fair/foul calls. Let the umps call the game.

[You Play to Win the Game]

Voth having a day.

[TwentyThirtyFive]

Voth having a day.

What a find and what work the pitching coaches have done. For the 3rd straight game Im shouting out Holt and his staff

[jamesdean]

To give the sport the NFL "feel."
I hate replay.
IMO, it should only be used for fan interference, fair/foul calls. Let the umps call the game.

I don't mind replay but get the call right! I don't know what the hell they were looking at. He was clearly safe. I didn't think it would even require multiple views.

[You Play to Win the Game]

Such good depth in that pen. These guys are nasty. Got Verlander out early only to face two guys with low 2’s.

Hope Hyde manages this like a playoff game from this point forward, especially with the off day tomorrow.

[85Knight]

Can Mountcastle be any worse right now.?