From the beginning Baxter had scoring ability in the low post. He flashed that as a freshman.
The other thing, I didn't like was how similar Cleare and Mitchell were as post players. You would prefer to have on guys that could be an explosive, rim protecting type guy. Neither are that. Again, if one can cement himself as a true low post scorer we'll be fine if the other is only a role player.
Baxter averaged about 1 more PPG than Mitchell as a freshman, while getting essentially the same minutes. And in Baxter's freshman year they had Obinna Ekeze and Mike Mardesich in the post, hardly guys that you would feed like they did Alex Len, so Lonny probably had more scoring chances. And also, Baxter had a year of prep school before going to UM, Mitchell came straight from high school.
All that could mean nothing in the end, but to write Mitchell off as nothing more than a role player after his first season at the college level is premature.
EDIT: Baxter made a huge jump from his freshman to sophomore season, so with Len gone and Cleare having back issues, we will see if Mitchell takes advantage of his opportunity.