It depends on your actual reasoning for bringing these threads up.
If they're just "interesting" because they are related to the debate, that's fine.
But if you're going for the "oh, got you!" angle that's just dirty pool.
And your "Good Post Nickle" comment suggests that that the latter was your actual motivation.
But hey, maybe I'm wrong.
You can think what you want, but that's a weird conclusion to reach IMO. I gave my reasoning. It is interesting to see what he said here. It's also very relevant to the current discussion on this. I also bumped two other threads today, because they were relevant to legacy/title talk. Ulterior motives there too?