I might get an X1 eventually, but not for a couple years into it, after a couple price breaks.
I pre-ordered a PS4. Yes, you now have to pay in order to play multiplayer, but I'd be getting their Plus service anyway so it doesn't really affect me. If I decided not to, I wouldn't be able to play online, but at least I would still have access to my entertainment apps, such as Netflix (which remains locked behind teh XBL Gold paywall unless they change things).
The only Xbox exclusive that ever really interested me was Halo, and I'll miss being able to play it at release, but I'll get over it. PS4 has plenty of exlusives announced, and it's also getting Bungie's new game and that Tom Clancy game, which are two titles I was pretty excited about. Going by the list, it looks like X1 has 8 exclusives announced at E3, while PS4 has 5 announced. It should be noted that the PS3 has 5 exclusives on the list, while the 360 has none.
http://i.imgur.com/ZWK5YzZ.png
Anyway, I've never had an issue with any of my PS systems, so I don't have the negative opinion of them that some others have. Likewise, I never got a RROD on my 360 so I never had an issue with any of my Xbox systems.
For me, it mostly comes down to price. If the X1 had a Kinect-less option for $399 I could see it being more competitive for me. Plus, Playstation gets more RPGs, since many JRPG don't end up on the Xbox, and that's a genre I quite enjoy.