I don’t see how we can rely on Tate, major injury that is one step before TJ and he has been getting shelled in AAA. Givens is better than Baker but not by a whole lot, IMO. But I would trust him more than Bake the Flake!
Baker should be a 5th - 8th guy in a pen.
If you look at him in that context, he's more than fine.
If you are asking him to be a high leverage guy, that's a bit much.