Balt Baseball.com: Evaluating Elias after 4 years with Orioles
https://www.baltimor...-years-orioles/
Posted 26 November 2022 - 10:26 AM
Balt Baseball.com: Evaluating Elias after 4 years with Orioles
https://www.baltimor...-years-orioles/
Posted 01 December 2022 - 06:27 PM
This doesn't feel like an evaluation. What's the overall evaluation based on this rollup of things? Agreed everyone may have a different take on the different aspects...that's the associated discussion/defense...but if you don't make some overall grades (or whatever)...have we done an evaluation?
Here's the list of topic areas identified by Dubroff. I added one at the end he refers to but doesn't isolate.
I think there's a number of contextual perspectives you could use to do this work, I don't think it matters which you choose if you describe it and stay consistent.
For the Super-cliff notes version I'll just include grades, may break out and discuss.
Off-field personnel: A-
On-field personnel: B
Orioles 40-man roster: C (not specific but I'd include ML 'player development' here)
Minor League Players: A- (not specific but I'd include MiL 'player development' here)
Trades: C
Waivers: A
International signings: B+
Winning: F
Overall: Incomplete
Posted 01 December 2022 - 09:51 PM
This doesn't feel like an evaluation. What's the overall evaluation based on this rollup of things? Agreed everyone may have a different take on the different aspects...that's the associated discussion/defense...but if you don't make some overall grades (or whatever)...have we done an evaluation?
Here's the list of topic areas identified by Dubroff. I added one at the end he refers to but doesn't isolate.
I think there's a number of contextual perspectives you could use to do this work, I don't think it matters which you choose if you describe it and stay consistent.
For the Super-cliff notes version I'll just include grades, may break out and discuss.
Off-field personnel: A-
On-field personnel: B
Orioles 40-man roster: C (not specific but I'd include ML 'player development' here)
Minor League Players: A- (not specific but I'd include MiL 'player development' here)
Trades: C
Waivers: A
International signings: B+
Winning: F
Overall: Incomplete
How is there not an overall grade.
0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users