8 replies to this topic

[Greg Pappas]

Just past the halfway point, and I'd like to see what YOUR views/grades are for each part of the team thus far this season AND what you expect these grades will be in 2013. If you don't expect a player will be here in 2013, then just note that. As well, I've left out a few guys that were part of the team as some point, but made limited contributions. There are a few players listed with limited time, but may be a part of 2013, so I kept them.

You can copy and past this as the template to use, or use your own. I left my grades for the team Ownership/Management as an example:

Ownership: D- / D-
GM: C / C
Manager/Coaching Staff: C / C

Hammel:
Chen:
Gonzalez:
Matusz:
Tillman:
Britton:
Arrieta:
Hunter:
J. Johnson:
Strop:
Patton:
Lindstrom:
Ayala:
Gregg:

C. Davis:
Reynolds:
Andino:
Roberts:
Tolleson:
Flaherty:
Hardy:
Betemit:
Avery:
Reimold:
Jones:
Markakis:
Pearce:
Chavez:
Wieters:
Paulino:
Teagarden:

Thome:

[ChaosLex]

Ownership: F
GM: C-
Manager/Coaching Staff: C+
Hammel: A-
Chen: B+
Gonzalez: B-
Matusz: D+
Tillman: D-
Britton: B
Arrieta: F
Hunter: F
J. Johnson: A-
Strop: B+
Patton: B
Lindstrom: B+
Ayala: B-
Gregg: B

C. Davis: D
Reynolds: D-
Andino: B
Roberts: D-
Tolleson: D
Flaherty: C
Hardy: C
Betemit: D+
Avery: D+
Reimold: C-
Jones: B+
Markakis: B
Pearce: D-
Chavez: D-
Wieters: A-
Paulino: F
Teagarden: B-

Thome: D+

[Greg Pappas]

Joseph... Are these grades solely based on this season, or did you include your views on 2013 into the one grade?

Also, I was a bit surprised by Chris Davis' grade and Andino's as well.

Davis: .260/.304/.449/.753
Andino= .230/.292/.325/.617

[SammyBirdland]

I think ChaosLex's player grades are pretty accurate. I would drop Wieters to a B due to inconsistent hitting.

I'd give Dan Duquette a C+, or an incomplete. He just hasn't had enough time yet for me to give him a fair evaluation. Many of the moves he's made so far have turned out to be good ones. I really need to see where he goes from here to determine if I'm satisfied.

[ChaosLex]

Joseph... Are these grades solely based on this season, or did you include your views on 2013 into the one grade?

Whoops! Current season. I'll go back and make some revisions.

[SportsGuy]

Ownership: G
GM: C
Manager/Coaching Staff: C

Hammel: a
Chen: a
Gonzalez: B
Matusz: C-
Tillman: C
Britton: inc
Arrieta: D
Hunter: D
J. Johnson: A
Strop: B
Patton: B
Lindstrom: B+
Ayala: B
Gregg: C

C. Davis: A
Reynolds: D
Andino: C
Roberts: inc
Tolleson: C
Flaherty: D
Hardy: D
Betemit: C
Avery: B
Reimold: inc
Jones: A
Markakis: B
Pearce: B
Chavez: F
Wieters: C
Paulino: C
Teagarden: inc

Thome: C

[Greg Pappas]

SG: Pretty good list, but Chris Davis an "A"?

[SportsGuy]

SG: Pretty good list, but Chris Davis an "A"?

He has shown to be a solid, bottom of the order bat who is making no money.

He isn't a DFA guy, so that gets a higher grade from me.

[LanceRinker]

Ownership: C- / B-
GM: C+ / B
Manager/Coaching Staff: C / B-

Hammel: A+/A
Chen: B+/B
Gonzalez:
Matusz: D/C
Tillman: C-/C
Britton: C/B
Arrieta: F/C-
Hunter: F/D
J. Johnson: A+/A
Strop: A/A
Patton: B-/B
Lindstrom: B/B
Ayala: A/won't be here
Gregg: D/won't be here

C. Davis: C/B-
Reynolds: F/won't be here
Andino: D/C-
Roberts: D/D
Tolleson: D+/C
Flaherty: D/C-
Hardy: D+/C+
Betemit: C+/C
Avery: C-/B-
Reimold: B/C+
Jones: A/A
Markakis: B-/B+
Pearce: B/B
Chavez: F/won't be here
Wieters: C/B+
Paulino: C/won't be here
Teagarden: D/C+

Thome: C/won't be here