That's the problem though, why should it matter from the one's that don't have a clue.
I get it, frustration, the feel like a change needs made, we all know I'm quick to come down on GM for stupid moves, BUT at the same time, there are MANY worse than him than there are better out there.
People are hoping we are about to find our Yzerman, but I promise you, he's one of a kind and it's a lot more likely to get our Garth Snow (shudder).
First off, I don't think Ted should be basing this decision on public opinion. That said "the fans that don't have a clue" (or the ones you disagree with) absolutely matter. If Ted brought back GMGM, it represents complacency.
I understand your position even though I disagree with it -- they make the playoffs nearly every year under GMGM even if they don't go far in the playoffs, so why risk that? Nevermind over 50% of the teams in the NHL make the playoffs.
Honestly Jeremy, what difference does it make? This team wasn't winning a cup with GMGM. I don't really care if they go on a Wizards esque run and miss the playoffs.
To quote Billy Beane (and Rob Shields): "You're either rebuilding for something special, or you're on the verge of something special. To be in between is foolish."
I'm not sure if they were never winning a Cup with GMGM, but they routinely underachieved. The owner, coaches, and players have all changed during his tenure, he remained the common denominator -- and aside from the beginning they haven't been able to get far. Is it completely his fault, of course not. But like anything else it's a results oriented business and the results weren't there.
After routine disappointment, I don't think this is a knee-jerk reaction. If anything, Ted should be faulted for sticking with him too long. He could've extended him and been happy with continued status quo, but he wants more. At this point, I think it's a good move. This move has it's risks but so does any move.
Ironically with the Billy Beane quote, I'd love someone to take him to task with this considering he hasn't won a game above the ALDS and only made it out of it once during his tenure as GM. Yeah I give him credit and all for what he's done in a pretty difficult situation but still.