Ok you know exactly what I'm saying. I'm asking if the player is good enough, do you overlook their flaws and take them on the team? Or does your K-Rod standard of refusing to accept them onto the team, apply across the board regardless of talent and/or ability level?
Well, your comment had nothing to do with what you quoted, so I gave the relevant response.
If Cabrera was arrested as opposed to being taken in for questioning...then, yes, if a player got drunk and beat on his woman ... yeah, I would find a way to get him off the roster. I would not tolerate someone beating his wife.. Some things go beyond winning.
I also think Os were way too lenient on Patton and his DUI. I would not release a player on a DUI, but he would be suspended harshly.