I still say the 2006 play-off loss to the Colts was the most brutal in team history. At least for me it was. I still get sick to my stomach thinking about it. Maybe because there was so much hype leading up to that game and the fact that defensively, we did a great job against Manning and STILL lost is hard to take even now.
Same, Colts kick 5 fgs 0 touchdowns and we still lose!? I remember every one wanting the Colts that year ( I didn't) Still remember Heaps fumble in the first quarter, a guy at the bar was giving me crap because I was wearing a Heap jersey, I was like wtf I'm not the one who fumbled.