Here's a name for you guys....LaMarr Hoyt. He really only had one great season, but it was great enough that he won the Cy Young pitching for the White Sox, who were the AL West Champs that season but lost to the O's in the ALCS. Yep, it was 1983.
Dominated the O's in Game 1 of the ALCS, and had we not won Game 4, he was set to go in the deciding Game 5. To this day I tell people that I was more excited to win the Tito Landrum game than the World Series clincher, and LaMarr Hoyt was the reason.